Skip to Content Skip to Content
Attorney General of Virginia Header

View Office of the Attorney General Expenditures



Lock Up Your Meds
News for CitizensOcwen MortgageMortgage Servicing Settlement Agreement
Computer Crime
Human Trafficking
Gang Prevention
Drug Take Back Program Line of Duty Death Claims
Medicaid Fraud
Elder Abuse and Neglect
TRIAD - Seniors
Official Opinions


State Seal
Commonwealth of Virginia
Office of the Attorney General

name and titleaddress



For media inquiries only, contact:  Brian J. Gottstein
Email: (best contact method)
Phone: 804-786-5874

AG Cuccinelli responds to EPA in court, underscoring agency's improper conduct in greenhouse gases ruling

~ Brief filed on behalf of Texas, Virginia, 13 other states ~

RICHMOND, VA (October 18, 2011)--Virginia Attorney General Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II announced today that his office has filed a response to the Environmental Protection Agency in his appeal of the agency's 2009 ruling that carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases are pollutants dangerous to human health.

The reply brief was filed Monday in the District of Columbia Circuit Court on behalf of Virginia, Texas, and 13 other states.  The brief argues the EPA did not follow its own rules when it used data from outside entities to arrive at the endangerment finding without testing that data according to its own research standards.  The brief also states that EPA improperly denied Virginia's and Texas's petition for reconsideration of the finding.

A copy of the brief can be found here.

The filing of the brief followed the release of the EPA's own inspector general's investigation in late September which showed that the agency did indeed fail to follow its own rules when it concluded greenhouse gases are a danger to human health.

In part, the reply brief states:

"We have asked the EPA since February 2010 to simply reopen its hearings and review its finding while following proper rules and procedures, as well as allow new, conflicting evidence that has become available since the original finding," the attorney general said in an October 5 statement.  "The EPA's failure to follow its own rules calls into question everything it has done.  Whenever a government agency states a conclusion that is allegedly based on science, but refuses to comply with its own rules that require it to 'show its work,' we should all be concerned."

"As attorney general, I do not file suit against the federal government because I disagree with it over a policy; I can only bring suit when the federal government does not follow the law or proper procedures," said Cuccinelli. "In fact, I recently commended the EPA for stopping an alleged Chesapeake Bay polluter," he said, referring to an October 14 statement. "When the EPA works within the bounds of its authority to enforce environmental regulations, I support its efforts to protect America's and Virginia's interests."

The inspector general's report can be found here.   In a statement issued two days after the report, the inspector general stated, "EPA disagreed with our conclusions and did not agree to take any corrective actions in response to this report."

Besides Virginia and Texas, the thirteen other states in the suit are Alabama, Florida, Indiana, Louisiana, Mississippi, Oklahoma, South Carolina, North Dakota, South Dakota, Utah, Nebraska, Michigan, and Kentucky.

More about Attorney General Cuccinelli

Photos of the attorney general

A copy of this news release may be found on the attorney general's web site here.

Follow the Office of the Attorney General's official posts on Facebook:

 Follow us on Facebook

# # #